Skip to content
Get started free

Test

Strong versus weak evidence

Students practise choosing which evidence is relevant and sufficient to support claims using short scenarios with follow-up questions. They decide between competing evidence and identify when evidence is relevant but not enough. Level: 8th grade.

By Edform · English language arts · Grade 8 · Published Oct 28, 2026 · New

A copy is added to your account. Change it however you like.

Questions

  1. A student claims the school should add shade near the playground because students are uncomfortable during hot afternoons. Which evidence best supports the claim?
  2. A student claims the school library should stay open later so more students can study there. Which additional evidence would most strengthen the claim?
  3. A claim states that the new school garden attracts pollinators. Which evidence best supports this claim?
  4. A student claims that longer lunch periods help students feel less rushed. Which evidence is relevant but not sufficient on its own?
  5. Put the steps for explaining how evidence supports a claim in a clear order.
  6. Match each evidence example to the best evaluation of its strength and relevance.
  7. Match each claim to the evidence that most directly supports it.
  8. Complete the sentence about evaluating evidence.
  9. Complete the sentence with a useful phrase for explaining evidence.
  10. Choose the best options to complete the sentence.

More like this